small pl CAMK logo

Journal Club



02.11.2026

"Revisiting the Young Stellar Populations of Collinder 205 and Ruprecht 79 with Near-Infrared Data"

Arthur Silva Magalhães (NCAC, Warsaw)


09.11.2026

"Globular cluster Observations for Luminosity-dispersion Distances (GOLD): Project description and velocity catalogue"

Ricardo Salinas (NCAC, Warsaw)

Based on https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.14181


16.11.2026

"Distinguishing black holes from naked singularities via Tidal Disruption events"

Gabriel Tyszka (NCAC, Warsaw)

Tidal disruption events (TDEs) occur when a compact object tears apart a star with its tidal forces. In the standard interpretation of observed TDEs, the disrupting object is assumed to be a black hole. However, the cosmic censorship conjecture remains unproven, and TDEs probe the strong-field regime close to the central object, making them a potentially useful test of alternatives such as naked singularities. In this talk, we investigate whether a naked singularity described by the Reissner-Nordström metric with Q > M can be distinguished from a black hole through observations of TDEs. We perform smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations of the disruption of a Sun-like star using the PHANTOM code, and compare the dynamics of the debris in both cases. We then use ray tracing to compute bolometric light curves and search for differences that could serve as observational signatures of a naked singularity. We discuss the preliminary results and their implications for testing cosmic censorship with TDEs.

Presenting his work